Themes

theme picker

Bleed Green Sports

Our Blood Runs Green — Our Takes Run Hot!

2027 NFL Draft QB Tiers - November 17th

2027 NFL Draft QB Tiers – November 17th

Howie Roseman’s pregame conversation with Darian Mensah becomes the story of the week, CJ Carr stays steady, and several first-round hopefuls deliver uneven performances.*

The two quarterbacks at the top strengthened their positions in very different ways. Carr followed his victory over Miami with an efficient win against Boston College. Mensah responded to his first loss by throwing for 382 yards against his former school, then became the center of Philadelphia’s draft conversation after cameras captured him greeting Eagles general manager Howie Roseman before the game.

The rest of the class experienced a difficult weekend. Arch Manning threw three interceptions before helping Texas escape LSU. Drew Mestemaker and Jayden Maiava each threw multiple interceptions in decisive losses. Trinidad Chambliss produced only 127 passing yards at Oklahoma, and LaNorris Sellers did not play against Arkansas while recovering from an ankle injury. Austin Simmons supplied one of the few positive developments with three touchdown passes at Georgia.

The Eagles should prioritize a quarterback who can command an NFL passing game from the pocket, recognize coverage, throw with anticipation and remain composed when the first answer disappears. Useful mobility strengthens that profile when it creates another throwing platform, avoids pressure or converts an open rushing lane. Philadelphia should remain open to every quarterback whose complete skill set can translate to the NFL.

These tiers combine 2026 performance, physical traits, positional value, NFL translation and the likelihood that each quarterback could enter the first 100 picks. They reflect information available through November 16, 2026. Players are listed alphabetically by surname within each tier, with no internal ordering.

Howie Roseman Daps Up Darian Mensah

The video is real and the interaction deserves attention. Roseman approached Mensah during pregame warmups before Miami’s 36-25 win over Duke, exchanged a friendly dap and spent time speaking with him. Roseman also greeted other players, and reporting indicated that more than 10 NFL teams had representatives at the game. The scene confirms that Roseman met and spoke with Mensah in Miami. It does not establish that the Eagles have decided to draft him. Eagles Wire reported the interaction and the family context, while Bleacher Report covered the video and ensuing draft speculation.

Roseman’s presence also had a personal explanation. His oldest son, Jake, attends Duke and contributes to the Blue Devils’ football program. Jake is reportedly a sophomore who has worked with the team during his first two years at the university. The Eagles were on their bye, giving Roseman an ideal opportunity to see his son and attend a game filled with NFL prospects. Bleeding Green Nation noted that the family connection could have been the primary reason for the trip.

The timeline creates an important overlap. Mensah was Duke’s starting quarterback throughout the 2025 season, when he threw for 3,973 yards, produced 34 touchdown passes and led the Blue Devils to the ACC championship. Jake Roseman’s first year around Duke football coincided with that entire season. He would have seen Mensah’s preparation, practice habits, interactions inside the program and response to the demands of a championship run. Public reporting does not establish the nature of their personal relationship, so the overlap should not be presented as proof that they were close.

That connection could still matter to an evaluator as thorough as Roseman. NFL teams spend enormous time investigating how quarterbacks prepare, lead, communicate and respond to adversity. Roseman potentially has access to someone he trusts who observed Mensah’s only season at Duke from inside the program. There is no public evidence that Jake has provided an evaluation to the Eagles, and any claim about a private scouting conversation would be speculation.

The complicated end of Mensah’s Duke tenure adds another layer. Mensah initially planned to return, entered the transfer portal, faced a lawsuit from Duke concerning his NIL agreement and eventually completed his move to Miami. The situation gives NFL teams additional questions involving communication, contractual expectations and the pressures surrounding modern college football. It also gives people who were present at Duke an unusually detailed view of how Mensah handled an uncomfortable transition. The Associated Press documented Duke’s lawsuit and Mensah’s production during the 2025 season.

Roseman’s conversation with Mensah should therefore be treated as a meaningful data point rather than a declaration of intent. The Eagles are positioned to study every top quarterback, and a general manager greeting one of them in November remains far removed from submitting a draft card in April. The family connection makes it plausible that Roseman knew plenty about Mensah before the dap, and the pregame video confirms that the two men have now met directly.

Tier 1: The QB1 Race

Carr maintains a narrow lead because he owns the head-to-head victory and has paired polished pocket play with excellent ball security. Mensah remains beside him after an immediate rebound against Duke and still owns the stronger full-season statistical profile.

CJ Carr, Notre Dame, Junior

6-foot-3, 210 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Carr is a polished pocket passer with a compact release, layered accuracy and a strong understanding of progression concepts. He moves efficiently inside the pocket, delivers accurately on rollouts and uses selective scrambles to preserve drives while maintaining a pass-first identity.

Season recap versus expectations: Carr completed 20 of 26 passes for 217 yards, two touchdowns and one interception as Notre Dame defeated Boston College 41-7. The interception came on a tipped pass and ended his remarkable run of ball security, leaving him at 197-of-288 passing for 2,385 yards, 23 touchdowns and two interceptions through 10 games. Carr entered the year with first-round expectations and has surpassed them through consistent accuracy, controlled decision-making and major wins. The Boston College performance was less demanding than the previous week’s Miami game, although it showed that Carr could return to ordinary execution after an emotional victory. Notre Dame’s official recap details his efficient afternoon.

Eagles translation: Carr remains the cleanest schematic fit for Philadelphia because his game begins with timing, anticipation and pocket discipline. He can execute a complete dropback offense, change launch points and find useful completions after protection begins to deteriorate. His evaluation now needs more evidence against disguised pressure and tight man coverage, especially in situations where Notre Dame cannot control the game around him.

Darian Mensah, Miami, Junior

6-foot-3, 205 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Mensah developed at Tulane, broke out during an ACC championship season at Duke and transferred to Miami for 2026. His game is built around calm feet, quick recognition and precise placement, with enough athletic ability to escape pressure while keeping his eyes downfield.

Season recap versus expectations: Mensah completed 30 of 41 passes for 382 yards, one touchdown and no interceptions as Miami defeated Duke 36-25. He was especially effective in the quick game, neutralizing pressure with decisive throws and generating 300 yards on passes traveling five air yards or fewer. Mensah has completed 242 of 317 passes for 3,083 yards, 29 touchdowns and two interceptions through 10 games. He entered the year as a possible first-round selection and has become one of the safest high-end evaluations in the class. His response to the Notre Dame loss also showed emotional control during a week filled with attention surrounding his return matchup against Duke. Miami’s official review covers his 382-yard performance.

Eagles translation: Mensah offers the pocket control, anticipation and accuracy Philadelphia should value. He processes quickly enough to defeat pressure with the ball, and his movement creates additional throwing opportunities without becoming the foundation of the offense. His ability to produce within structure, limit turnovers and handle high-volume passing assignments gives him a direct path into an NFL starting lineup.

Tier 2: First-Round Cases Under Review

Manning, Mestemaker and Sellers retain first-round paths because their complete résumés and physical traits remain compelling. Each carries a significant November question involving turnovers, performance against top competition or health.

Arch Manning, Texas, Senior

6-foot-4, 222 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Manning combines a quick release and above-average arm talent with legitimate speed as a runner. His strongest sequences feature anticipatory throws, manipulation of the middle-field defender and efficient movement inside the pocket, while his difficult stretches include delayed decisions and unstable placement.

Season recap versus expectations: Manning completed 19 of 35 passes for 174 yards, one touchdown and three interceptions in Texas’ 22-21 win at LSU. He also ran for 35 yards and a touchdown, then helped direct the late possession that produced the winning score. Manning has completed 187 of 289 passes for 2,198 yards, 19 touchdowns and 10 interceptions through 10 games. His toughness and late-game composure continue to create valuable wins, while the interception total has become impossible to separate from his draft evaluation. He entered the year with No. 1 overall expectations and currently presents a volatile first-round case built around traits, flashes and competitive responses. Texas’ official box score documents the entire performance.

Eagles translation: Manning has the physical range to execute every major component of an NFL offense. He can win from the pocket, create a second throwing opportunity and punish open space as a runner. Philadelphia would need to determine whether stronger protection rules, refined footwork and professional coaching can reduce the risky decisions that have repeatedly placed Texas in difficult situations.

Drew Mestemaker, Oklahoma State, Sophomore

6-foot-3, approximately 215 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Mestemaker developed from a high school backup and college walk-on into the 2025 national passing leader at North Texas. He followed coach Eric Morris to Oklahoma State and has carried his loose release, movement accuracy and aggressive downfield approach into stronger competition.

Season recap versus expectations: Mestemaker completed 27 of 42 passes for 277 yards, one touchdown and two interceptions in Oklahoma State’s 52-27 loss to Texas Tech. The game ended his streak of eight consecutive performances with at least 300 passing yards and two passing touchdowns. He now has 3,239 yards, 30 touchdowns and 10 interceptions on 233-of-351 passing through 10 games. Mestemaker has exceeded every reasonable preseason expectation and remains one of the country’s most productive passers. The Texas Tech loss reinforces concerns about how his aggressive style holds up when a fast defense creates pressure, changes the coverage picture and forces him to play from behind. Oklahoma State’s official box score provides his complete line.

Eagles translation: Mestemaker’s arm talent, spatial feel and accuracy on the move create genuine NFL starting upside. Philadelphia could develop him within a pocket-oriented system while using play action and movement throws to access his creativity. He needs additional experience setting protections, identifying simulated pressure and accepting underneath completions before a defense turns his aggression into turnovers.

LaNorris Sellers, South Carolina, Junior

6-foot-3, 240 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Sellers is the most physically imposing quarterback in the group, combining a powerful arm with running-back size and open-field explosiveness. His strength allows him to survive contact, create after protection fails and challenge every level of the field, while his mechanics and processing require greater consistency.

Season recap versus expectations: Sellers was available against Arkansas after dealing with an ankle injury, though South Carolina started Cutter Woods and did not use Sellers during the 34-6 loss. His statistics remain 172-of-274 passing for 2,100 yards, 17 touchdowns and seven interceptions, along with substantial rushing production. Sellers had created positive momentum through three consecutive strong performances before the injury interrupted his season. He entered the year with No. 1 overall expectations and has produced enough high-level tape to preserve a first-round path, though his health and late-season availability now require close attention. The SEC’s postgame review confirmed that Sellers was available if needed and that South Carolina did not violate the conference reporting policy.

Eagles translation: Sellers would give Philadelphia the broadest physical playbook in the class. He can drive deep throws, punish man coverage as a runner and escape contact that ends plays for most quarterbacks. His professional ceiling remains extremely high, and reaching it will require quicker progression work, repeatable footwork, improved routine accuracy and a complete return from the ankle injury.

Tier 3: Top-100 Talents With Uneven Tape

Maiava and Simmons possess NFL starter traits and enough production to remain firmly in the top-100 conversation. Their cases currently lack the down-to-down consistency needed for a comfortable first-round projection.

Jayden Maiava, USC, Senior

6-foot-4, 230 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Maiava is a well-built, experienced passer with a strong arm and functional mobility. His college path through Vanderbilt, UNLV and USC has exposed him to several systems, and his best tape shows a quarterback capable of attacking vertically, using play action and creating outside structure.

Season recap versus expectations: Maiava completed 26 of 42 passes for 311 yards, one touchdown and three interceptions as USC lost 27-13 at Indiana. He moved the ball between the 20s and was not sacked, though the turnovers prevented USC from converting yardage into sustained scoring. Maiava now has 2,836 yards, 21 touchdowns and eight interceptions through 10 games. His season remains ahead of the middle-round expectations he carried into September, with two three-interception losses creating a recurring concern about risk management. The Ohio State win demonstrates his first-round ceiling, while the Wisconsin and Indiana losses explain his move into this tier. USC’s official box score documents his 311-yard performance.

Eagles translation: Maiava gives Philadelphia useful pocket size, vertical arm strength and movement ability. He can attack outside the numbers and create explosive plays without requiring a run-heavy quarterback system. His NFL projection depends on faster recognition of rotating coverage and a willingness to end possessions with an incompletion instead of forcing the ball into danger.

Austin Simmons, Missouri, Senior

6-foot-4, 220 pounds | Left-handed

Player snapshot: Simmons transferred from Ole Miss to Missouri and owns one of the strongest arms in the class. He can drive the far hash, generate velocity from imperfect platforms and attack vertically, with adequate mobility for navigating pressure.

Season recap versus expectations: Simmons completed 17 of 25 passes for 175 yards, three touchdowns and one interception in Missouri’s 48-21 loss at No. 1 Georgia. The early interception contributed to a difficult start, and his three scoring throws showed that he continued competing after the game moved out of reach. Simmons has completed 192 of 308 passes for 2,379 yards, 21 touchdowns and three interceptions through 10 games. His turnover rate remains one of the best features on the board and places him well ahead of his preseason expectations. Inconsistent placement and limited production against the strongest opponents continue to keep him outside the first-round tier. Missouri’s official recap covers his three-touchdown effort.

Eagles translation: Simmons has the pocket-oriented physical profile Philadelphia should continue studying. His arm can expand the field horizontally and vertically, and he moves well enough to create a second throwing platform. The remaining evaluation must identify whether his placement issues originate with footwork, recognition, timing or discomfort after the first read is removed.

Tier 4: The Top-100 Bubble

Chambliss remains a viable draft prospect through his experience, mobility and overall production. Three difficult games against high-level defenses have pushed him toward the edge of the first 100 selections.

Trinidad Chambliss, Ole Miss, Fifth Year Plus

6-foot-0, 210 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Chambliss brings extensive starting experience after moving from Division II Ferris State to Ole Miss. His quick release, sturdy frame and rushing ability provide answers against pressure, while his height affects the evaluation of throws through congested areas.

Season recap versus expectations: Chambliss completed 14 of 27 passes for 127 yards, one touchdown and no interceptions in Ole Miss’ 24-17 loss at Oklahoma. He added 84 rushing yards and generated several of the Rebels’ most productive plays with his legs, though the passing offense rarely threatened Oklahoma downfield. Chambliss has completed 221 of 357 passes for 2,486 yards, 19 touchdowns and nine interceptions through 10 games. His season remains far ahead of his original projection after arriving from Division II football. The Texas, Georgia and Oklahoma performances have created a troubling late-season pattern involving pocket vision, passing efficiency and answers against fast defenses. Oklahoma’s official box score provides his passing and rushing totals.

Eagles translation: Chambliss can operate a varied offense featuring shotgun concepts, play action, movement passes and selective quarterback runs. His experience and creativity provide solutions when protection breaks down. Philadelphia must decide whether his middle-field vision, size and aggressive decisions can support a stable NFL passing game when opponents contain his movement and close throwing windows quickly.

Tier 5: Medical Hold

Moore and Sayin still possess early-round talent. Their placements reflect major medical uncertainty and the absence of new evaluation tape.

Dante Moore, Oregon, Senior

6-foot-3, 220 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Moore pairs smooth mechanics, touch and accuracy with enough arm talent to attack every level. He returned to Oregon after receiving first-round consideration for the 2026 draft, seeking another season of pocket development before suffering a serious concussion against USC.

Season recap versus expectations: Moore remains at 69-of-99 passing for 926 yards, nine touchdowns and no interceptions across four starts. Oregon has now ruled him out for the remainder of the 2026 season, formally ending an evaluation that contains fewer than 100 attempts. His efficient production supports the early-round talent visible on previous tape, while the injury, limited sample and incomplete pressure evaluation create significant uncertainty. Moore entered the year with a chance to establish himself near the top of the class, and medical confidence now controls whether that remains possible. Oregon’s official update explains the program’s outlook.

Eagles translation: A healthy Moore has the accuracy, touch and pocket poise Philadelphia should value. He moves well enough to avoid pressure, reset his platform and attack space without relying on designed runs. The Eagles would need extensive medical confidence and a clear development plan before attaching an early selection to his previous grade.

Julian Sayin, Ohio State, Junior

6-foot-1, 214 pounds | Right-handed

Player snapshot: Sayin is an accurate rhythm passer whose processing speed and repeatable mechanics create completions before the rush arrives. His game offers modest designed-run value, with pocket movement serving as his primary athletic contribution.

Season recap versus expectations: Sayin remains at 131-of-192 passing for 2,007 yards, 19 touchdowns and four interceptions through seven games. He continues to recover from the right arm injury suffered at Indiana and has not added new tape since October. His downfield production exceeded the expectations created by his 2025 short-game profile, while his size, outside-the-numbers velocity and recovery of the throwing arm remain central to his grade. Sayin entered the season as an efficient contender who needed to expand his passing profile, and he accomplished much of that before the injury interrupted his year. The Associated Press’ review of the playoff picture notes that Ohio State continues to operate without its injured starter.

Eagles translation: Sayin would bring quick processing, anticipation and short-to-intermediate accuracy to Philadelphia. A professional offense could emphasize those strengths through quick-game concepts, option routes and layered throws between zone defenders. His projection depends on complete recovery and evidence that his narrower physical margins can withstand NFL pressure.

The Eagles’ Best Fits on November 17th

Carr remains the strongest pure schematic fit because his game is built around timing, anticipation, accuracy and disciplined pocket movement. He has also produced the best head-to-head result in the class by outplaying Mensah. His combination of physical adequacy and advanced passing structure gives Philadelphia a clean foundation for an NFL offense.

Mensah sits extremely close and offers the stronger statistical résumé. He has already topped 3,000 yards with 29 touchdowns and two interceptions, and his quick processing would give the Eagles an immediate answer against pressure. The Duke connection and Roseman interaction make him the most relevant name for Philadelphia this week, though the evaluation should remain grounded in his complete tape.

Manning, Mestemaker and Sellers have broader variance. Manning owns the pedigree, physical range and late-game confidence to rise quickly if he controls the turnovers. Mestemaker has exceptional production and limited experience. Sellers possesses the greatest physical ceiling and requires the largest projection as a conventional NFL passer.

Maiava and Simmons retain starter-level tools, with decision-making separating Maiava from the first-round group and placement consistency limiting Simmons. Chambliss needs a strong finish to stop his slide toward the middle rounds. Moore and Sayin remain medical evaluations before they can become realistic draft targets.

Brendan Sorsby’s Completely Fictional Betting Desk

Satire notice: Everything in this section is a joke. It does not allege that Brendan Sorsby placed these wagers, won money, used inside information or influenced any game. Sorsby remains outside the quarterback tiers because he is not playing in 2026.

Sorsby’s imaginary weekend parlay included Mensah over 350 passing yards, Carr completing at least 75 percent of his passes, Simmons throwing three touchdowns, Chambliss rushing for more than 75 yards and Mestemaker finishing below 300 passing yards for the first time in nine games. The fictional ticket hit so cleanly that the pretend sportsbook asked whether Jake Roseman had been supplying the picks from Duke’s film room.

His made-up Texas and LSU single-game card was even more unreasonable. Manning over two interceptions, Manning anytime rushing touchdown, Texas moneyline and a winning score in the final minute all cashed. The imaginary risk manager reportedly stared at the ticket, turned off the television and applied for a peaceful new career evaluating long snappers.

The completely fabricated Miami card listed Mensah for 30 completions, 380 passing yards, no interceptions and a pregame dap with an NFL general manager. The first three legs were available only in Sorsby’s imaginary sportsbook. The fourth was added after the fact because even a fictional betting operation knows when the content is too good to ignore.

Word is Sorsby is betting big that Mensah lands with the Eagles in the NFL 2027 draft. We are unable to confirm this report.

For the factual portion, Sorsby is sitting out the 2026 season after the NCAA made him permanently ineligible for gambling violations, and he remains eligible for the regular 2027 NFL Draft. NFL.com reported his draft status, while the Associated Press covered the NCAA case.

About the Author

JC Stacs

NFL Research & analysis | data first | facts over feelings

JC Stacs is an NFL and NBA research analyst providing data-first sports coverage for Bleed Green Sports. Specializing in organizational trends, historical events, and analytical deep-dives, his work prioritizes critical thinking, factual research, and objective sports journalism over pure fandom and team cheerleading.


[View all articles by JC Stacs]