Themes

theme picker

Bleed Green Sports

Our Blood Runs Green — Our Takes Run Hot!

Philadelphia Eagles 2026 Midseason Awards

Philadelphia Eagles 2026 Midseason Awards: The Good, the Bad, and the God-Awful

The Philadelphia Eagles entered the 2026 season with championship aspirations, an expensive roster, an established coaching staff, and an organization that believed it could remain among the NFL’s elite. Nine games later, the Eagles are 2-7, riding a seven-game losing streak, and facing questions that extend well beyond their chances of making the playoffs.

For a franchise that entered the season expecting to compete for another Lombardi Trophy, the first half has been an organizational embarrassment. The offense has cycled through quarterbacks, the defense has struggled to meet expectations, and the offseason acquisitions have delivered remarkably little return on the organization’s investments.

The two primary avenues for improving a football team, free agency and the NFL Draft, have been particularly disappointing. Philadelphia’s 2026 free-agent class has been god-awful, while its rookie class has produced only a few encouraging performances. That combination has exposed a roster whose reputation is considerably more impressive than its results.

Nevertheless, several players have distinguished themselves despite the team’s failures. Some have performed at an elite level, others have exceeded modest expectations, and a few have provided legitimate reasons for optimism beyond this season.

Bleed Green Sports is handing out its 2026 Midseason Awards, recognizing the players who deserve credit, those who deserve criticism, and the people responsible for a season that has gone terribly wrong. We’ll conclude with a few special awards for the coaches and executives who have made this season such an unforgettable experience, although probably not in the way they intended.

Individual Excellence

Offensive MVP: Jordan Mailata

Honorable Mention: Makai Lemon

Jordan Mailata has been the most reliable player on an Eagles offense that has struggled in virtually every meaningful category. While quarterback instability, injuries, and ineffective execution have undermined the unit, Mailata has continued performing at a level expected from one of the NFL’s premier left tackles.

According to Pro Football Focus, Mailata carries an 85.5 overall grade through nine games, ranking fourth among qualifying offensive tackles. His individual consistency is particularly impressive considering the instability elsewhere along Philadelphia’s offensive line.

The Eagles have allowed 30 sacks through nine games, and the running game has been a disappointment despite the presence of Saquon Barkley. Mailata cannot compensate for every breakdown elsewhere, but he has demonstrated the level of professionalism and performance that this organization desperately needs from its other highly compensated veterans.

Rookie Makai Lemon receives honorable mention for becoming Philadelphia’s leading receiver despite the revolving door at quarterback. His production has been modest by NFL standards, but leading this offense in receptions and receiving yards as a rookie deserves recognition.

Defensive MVP: Quinyon Mitchell

Honorable Mention: Jalen Carter

Quinyon Mitchell has continued establishing himself as one of the NFL’s premier young cornerbacks, even as the Eagles’ secondary has struggled to maintain the standard established in previous seasons. His individual performance has been especially valuable considering the disappointing play surrounding him.

Through nine games, Mitchell has recorded an interception and nine passes defended while allowing approximately 305 receiving yards. His ability to challenge opposing receivers, maintain disciplined coverage, and limit explosive plays has been one of the few consistent strengths of Philadelphia’s defense.

Mitchell’s value becomes even more apparent when evaluating Cooper DeJean and Riq Woolen, both of whom entered the season with substantial expectations. Philadelphia needed its secondary to function as a collective strength, but Mitchell has frequently been the player keeping the unit respectable.

Jalen Carter receives honorable mention after recording five sacks through nine games, tying Nolan Smith for the team lead. Carter has provided valuable interior disruption, although the consistency expected from a player of his considerable talent remains a reasonable area of criticism.

Rookie of the Year: Makai Lemon

Honorable Mention: Markel Bell

Makai Lemon earns Rookie of the Year almost by default, which says as much about Philadelphia’s disappointing rookie class as it does about Lemon’s individual performance.

The first-round selection has recorded 37 receptions for 312 yards and a touchdown through nine games, leading the Eagles in both receptions and receiving yards. Those numbers are hardly spectacular for a receiver selected in the first round, but Lemon has demonstrated enough technical ability, reliability, and competitive toughness to suggest he can become a productive long-term contributor.

The larger concern is what Philadelphia has received from the remainder of its eight-player draft class. Second-round tight end Eli Stowers missed the first six games with an injury, while most of the later selections have contributed little to the team’s immediate fortunes.

Markel Bell receives honorable mention because he has been forced into significant playing time at right tackle and has demonstrated encouraging improvement. His performance has been inconsistent, but the rookie’s Week 9 outing against the Giants was among his strongest, offering some evidence that his development is moving in the right direction.

For a team that invested heavily in veterans while supposedly preparing its next generation of talent, the lack of immediate contributions from the rookie class is another troubling development.

Breakout Player: Makai Lemon

Honorable Mention: Eli Stowers

Lemon earns his second award for a different reason. Rookie of the Year recognizes his production relative to the rest of his draft class, while Breakout Player recognizes his emergence as a legitimate offensive contributor.

Philadelphia entered the season with established receivers DeVonta Smith and Hollywood Brown, along with Dallas Goedert at tight end. Yet Lemon has become the team’s leading receiver despite playing with three different starting quarterbacks and operating in an offense that has struggled to create consistent opportunities.

His receiving totals have been limited by the circumstances surrounding him, but his early development suggests that the Eagles have at least identified a player capable of growing into a prominent offensive role. That matters considerably for an organization whose future quarterback situation remains unresolved.

Eli Stowers receives honorable mention based on his potential and limited flashes since returning from injury. The second-round tight end has recorded three receptions for 53 yards in three appearances, a small sample that nevertheless offers some encouragement about his ability to contribute as a receiving weapon.

Best Offseason Acquisition

Best Free Agent Pickup: Arnold Ebiketie

Honorable Mention: Dameon Pierce

When Arnold Ebiketie is your best free-agent acquisition, your offseason personnel department should probably reconsider its definition of success.

Ebiketie has appeared in all nine games, recording 25 tackles while contributing substantial defensive snaps despite failing to register a sack. His statistical production has been limited, but he has consistently demonstrated effort, physicality, and a willingness to compete throughout a difficult season.

His relatively modest $1.3 million base salary also deserves consideration, although his one-year contract included $4.3 million in guarantees and was reportedly worth up to $7.3 million with incentives. Compared with the much larger commitments Philadelphia made elsewhere, Ebiketie has at least provided dependable availability and consistent effort for a comparatively restrained investment.

There is also something particularly ironic about the Eagles reportedly agreeing to trade Ebiketie to Cincinnati before the deal collapsed over the Bengals’ compensatory draft-pick considerations. One of Philadelphia’s more dependable offseason additions nearly became another departure before the organization had even completed his first season.

Dameon Pierce receives honorable mention for providing useful depth and physical running despite a limited role. He contributed 96 rushing yards before landing on injured reserve, and his effort was worthy of recognition even if his overall impact was modest.

The broader verdict on Philadelphia’s free-agent class remains devastating. When availability, effort, and relatively inexpensive contributions are sufficient to win the category, the front office has failed to acquire the difference-makers this roster desperately needed.

Resurgence and Redemption

Comeback Player of the Year: Nolan Smith

Honorable Mention: Darius Cooper

Nolan Smith has provided one of the few genuinely encouraging developments on Philadelphia’s defense, rebounding from an injury-interrupted 2025 season to become one of the team’s most productive pass rushers.

Smith recorded three sacks in 12 games last season but has already accumulated five through eight appearances in 2026. His return to productive football has been especially important given the disappointing performances of Jonathan Greenard and Jalyx Hunt, two players the Eagles expected to make significant contributions along the edge.

Smith’s explosiveness, relentless effort, and ability to create pressure have helped compensate for a defensive front that has failed to produce consistently. If he can remain healthy and maintain his production over the remaining eight games, Philadelphia will have at least one encouraging answer concerning its future at the position.

Darius Cooper receives honorable mention for establishing a meaningful role in the offense during his second NFL season. His 13 receptions for 200 yards and four touchdowns have made him Philadelphia’s leading touchdown receiver, an impressive scoring contribution considering the offense has produced only 10 passing touchdowns overall.

Rebound Player of the Year: Jake Elliott

Jake Elliott entered the season facing legitimate concerns about whether his best years were behind him. After converting only 20 of 27 field-goal attempts in 2025, a disappointing 74.1 percent success rate, Philadelphia had reason to question the reliability of a kicker who had previously been among the NFL’s best.

Through nine games in 2026, Elliott has converted seven of eight field-goal attempts, improving his accuracy to 87.5 percent. He is also perfect on all 17 extra-point attempts and has connected from as far as 58 yards, providing some stability in a season characterized by widespread inconsistency.

The sample size remains relatively small because Philadelphia’s offense has struggled to generate scoring opportunities. Nevertheless, Elliott has responded to criticism with improved performance, and his resurgence deserves recognition regardless of the team’s record.

Disappointments and Failures

Most Disappointing Player: Cooper DeJean

Honorable Mention: Jalyx Hunt

Cooper DeJean entered the 2026 season with expectations that extended well beyond simply being a productive defensive back. After establishing himself as an All-Pro talent, DeJean appeared capable of becoming one of the foundational pieces of Philadelphia’s defense for the foreseeable future.

Instead, his performance has fallen considerably short of that standard. DeJean has struggled to maintain the consistency that made him such a valuable player, and the secondary has suffered as a result.

The disappointment is magnified by his responsibilities within Vic Fangio’s defense. DeJean’s versatility, instincts, and ability to contribute against both the run and pass previously made him a matchup problem for opposing offenses. Philadelphia has needed those qualities throughout 2026, but he has not consistently delivered the level of play that earned him his reputation.

DeJean remains talented enough to reverse his fortunes, and nine disappointing games should not erase everything he accomplished previously. However, established standards matter when evaluating highly regarded players, and his regression has been one of the more troubling individual developments of the season.

Jalyx Hunt receives honorable mention after entering the year with expectations of becoming a breakout defensive star. Injuries have affected his availability and effectiveness, but reaching the bye without a sack represents a considerable disappointment for a player Philadelphia expected to develop into a major contributor.

Biggest Bust: Jonathan Greenard

Honorable Mention: Riq Woolen

Jonathan Greenard represents one of the most disappointing investments of Philadelphia’s offseason, and his struggles have consequences that extend well beyond the current season.

The Eagles acquired Greenard from Minnesota during the NFL Draft and subsequently agreed to a four-year, $100 million extension that reportedly included $50 million fully guaranteed. Philadelphia was investing in an established veteran pass rusher expected to help anchor its defensive front and provide the production necessary to compete against elite offenses.

Through nine games, Greenard has registered only one sack.

Injuries have affected his season, and sack totals do not provide a complete evaluation of an edge defender’s performance. Nevertheless, Philadelphia committed significant resources to acquiring Greenard, and the organization has received nowhere near the production necessary to justify that investment.

The opportunity cost makes the transaction particularly troubling. Philadelphia surrendered draft capital while committing substantial future financial resources to a veteran whose immediate impact has been negligible. Those decisions limit the organization’s flexibility at precisely the moment when its roster requires significant improvement.

Riq Woolen receives honorable mention because his acquisition was similarly expected to address a major defensive need. His disappointing performance has created another expensive personnel problem for an organization already struggling with the consequences of its offseason decisions.

Worst Free Agent Pickup: Riq Woolen

Honorable Mentions (Tie): Andy Dalton and Hollywood Brown

Riq Woolen arrived in Philadelphia with the physical attributes and experience necessary to strengthen the Eagles’ secondary. At 6-foot-4, Woolen offered rare length and athleticism at cornerback, and his previous success in Seattle suggested he could provide the complement Quinyon Mitchell needed.

Philadelphia reportedly committed $12 million fully guaranteed on a one-year contract, with a maximum value of $15 million. That substantial investment carried expectations of reliable starting-caliber performance and greater stability in the secondary.

Unfortunately, Woolen has struggled to provide either.

His inconsistent coverage and costly mistakes have contributed to a secondary that has repeatedly failed to deliver the performance expected from its talent. Woolen’s struggles have also increased the pressure on Mitchell, who has remained one of the defense’s more dependable contributors.

Andy Dalton and Hollywood Brown share honorable mention, although Dalton technically arrived through a trade rather than free agency. Dalton’s acquisition has provided little meaningful value to the quarterback situation, while Brown has failed to deliver the receiving production and veteran stability Philadelphia expected from his signing.

In an offseason filled with questionable acquisitions, Woolen stands out because of the combination of financial commitment, positional importance, and disappointing results.

Coaching Accountability

Worst Position Coach: Chris Kuper, Offensive Line

Honorable Mention: Clint Hurtt, Defensive Line

Chris Kuper inherited one of the NFL’s most respected offensive line units, a position group that had long been central to Philadelphia’s offensive identity. Nine games into his first season as the Eagles’ offensive line coach, the results have been deeply disappointing.

Philadelphia’s quarterbacks have been sacked 30 times, while the rushing attack has struggled to establish the physical dominance that previously defined the team. Injuries and personnel changes have complicated Kuper’s responsibilities, but the lack of cohesion, inconsistent protection, and repeated breakdowns have become impossible to ignore.

Jordan Mailata’s excellent individual performance further illustrates the disparity between the talent available and the results being produced elsewhere. The Eagles still possess accomplished veterans and promising young players, yet the offensive line has frequently looked like a collection of individuals rather than a coordinated unit.

Kuper inherited a demanding assignment, especially following the long tenure of Jeff Stoutland, but Philadelphia hired him to maintain a championship standard. At the midway point, the decline in offensive line performance has been one of the most damaging developments of the season.

Clint Hurtt receives honorable mention for the defensive line’s inconsistent performance despite significant investment in the position group. Although Jalen Carter and Nolan Smith have produced individual highlights, the overall unit has struggled to generate dependable pressure, and Philadelphia’s decision to trade Jordan Davis further illustrates the uncertainty surrounding its defensive front.

The Unofficial Awards: A Season of Organizational Misery

The traditional awards recognize individual performance and coaching effectiveness. However, a 2-7 record, seven consecutive losses, and an organization facing serious questions about its future deserve a few additional categories.

These are Bleed Green Sports’ satirical awards, intended to capture the absurdity of Philadelphia’s season rather than serve as actual quotations from the recipients.

The “100% Accountable, 0% Solutions” Award: Nick Sirianni

Nick Sirianni has never appeared particularly uncomfortable accepting responsibility for the Eagles’ failures. Accountability has become a familiar part of his public messaging, but the meaningful question is what that accountability actually produces.

The same problems have continued appearing week after week, and the organization has shown little ability to correct them. Seven consecutive losses suggest that acknowledging mistakes has become considerably easier than finding solutions, leaving Sirianni presiding over a season in which expressions of responsibility have produced virtually no meaningful improvement.

The “I’m Too Old for This Shit” Award: Vic Fangio

Vic Fangio has spent decades coaching football, developing defensive systems, and frustrating opposing quarterbacks. At this point in his career, he probably expected to spend his time refining an established championship defense rather than managing a collection of expensive disappointments.

Instead, Fangio has watched experienced defenders underperform, promising young players regress, and an organization invest significant resources without receiving the expected results. There is only so much defensive ingenuity available to compensate for poor execution, and this season has provided more than enough reasons to test the patience of even the most experienced coordinator.

The “Rather Be Watching the Phillies” Award: Vic Fangio

Fangio earns a second award because the Eagles’ season has become so miserable that even Philadelphia’s other sports teams must seem like an attractive alternative.

Given the defensive struggles and the endless questions surrounding this roster, the idea of spending an evening watching the Phillies rather than examining another breakdown in coverage probably sounds appealing. Unfortunately, baseball season is over, and Fangio still has eight games remaining to solve problems that should have been addressed months ago.

The “I’m Too Young for This Shit” Award: Sean Mannion

Sean Mannion entered 2026 as a first-time NFL play-caller responsible for leading an offense expected to compete for a championship. Instead, he has inherited quarterback uncertainty, ineffective blocking, inconsistent execution, and an increasingly frustrated fan base.

Bleed Green Sports questioned the decision to entrust such an important responsibility to an inexperienced coordinator before the regular season even began in The Mannion Honeymoon Is Over!. The subsequent failures have reinforced those concerns, and Mannion is learning that developing an offense and rescuing a dysfunctional one are two very different challenges.

The “I’m Too Scared for This Shit” Award: Howie Roseman

Howie Roseman has built his reputation on aggressive personnel management, creative financial maneuvering, and a willingness to make unconventional decisions. Unfortunately, his 2026 roster has become an expensive collection of questionable investments, declining performances, and unresolved problems.

Roseman’s challenge now requires more than another trade or a creative contract adjustment. The organization must confront difficult decisions about its quarterback situation, coaching staff, and veteran core, with some of those decisions potentially involving players and coaches who helped deliver previous success. The longer those decisions are postponed, the more difficult and expensive they may become.

The “I’m Staying in Florida” Award: Jeffrey Lurie

Jeffrey Lurie has enjoyed the benefits of owning one of the NFL’s most successful franchises, including multiple Super Bowl appearances and championships. The 2026 season has offered a considerably less enjoyable experience, with the Eagles collapsing into the NFC East basement.

The imaginary appeal of remaining in Florida rather than returning to Philadelphia to answer questions about the franchise is understandable. Unfortunately for Lurie, the problems facing his organization will require ownership-level decisions regardless of the weather, and the responsibility for evaluating the people running the football operation ultimately belongs to him.

The “Saturdays Are the Best Days” Award: Philadelphia Eagles Scouting Department

For Philadelphia’s scouting department, Saturdays must look considerably more promising than Sundays. College football offers talented prospects, exciting possibilities, and the comforting belief that the next draft class might finally address the deficiencies appearing on the Eagles’ roster.

The irony is that Philadelphia’s 2026 rookie class has produced little immediate impact beyond Makai Lemon and some encouraging development from Markel Bell. After investing eight selections in the draft, the organization has received remarkably little assistance from its newest players, making Saturdays an attractive opportunity to evaluate the next generation while hoping the current one eventually delivers.

Final Word: Eight Games Left, and Plenty to Answer For

The first nine games of Philadelphia’s 2026 season have exposed problems extending throughout the organization. The Eagles have received outstanding contributions from Jordan Mailata and Quinyon Mitchell, encouraging development from Makai Lemon, and valuable individual performances from Jalen Carter, Nolan Smith, and Jake Elliott. Unfortunately, those accomplishments have been overwhelmed by collective failures on both sides of the football.

The most troubling aspect of this season is the organization’s inability to convert its substantial investments into results. Philadelphia committed significant resources to veteran acquisitions while using another draft class to replenish its future talent, yet neither strategy has delivered an acceptable return through nine games.

The remaining eight games should become an extensive evaluation of the roster, coaching staff, and organizational philosophy. Players must demonstrate that they belong in Philadelphia’s future, coaches must establish that they can develop and deploy the talent available, and the front office must acknowledge the consequences of decisions that have contributed to this collapse.

The Eagles entered 2026 expecting another championship run. At the midway point, their most important challenge may be determining who deserves to return in 2027.

About the Author

JC Stacs

NFL Research & analysis | data first | facts over feelings

JC Stacs is an NFL and NBA research analyst providing data-first sports coverage for Bleed Green Sports. Specializing in organizational trends, historical events, and analytical deep-dives, his work prioritizes critical thinking, factual research, and objective sports journalism over pure fandom and team cheerleading.


[View all articles by JC Stacs]